This page is the DICTIONARY. It says what each code MEANS — the definition of each code,
and what the code includes and excludes — so you can decide whether it is the right one. For the
full value list and how the codes nest, use the
complete event taxonomy.
code=03 is the way to ask for “expressed intent to cooperate” without choosing a leaf.
Diplomatic, cooperative, verbal-conflict, and non-violent coercive political events. The boundary with ACLED is DID IT HAPPEN, OR WAS IT SAID: everything spoken — a threat, warning, demand, ultimatum or accusation — is a speech act and is coded here, however violent its subject matter, while physical violence, arrests of political figures (173) and violent repression of protesters (175) that ACTUALLY OCCURRED belong to ACLED. At least one actor must be a national government body, government agency, international organization, or named political figure of national or international prominence; purely local administrative routine (city council votes, local school board decisions, municipal budget approvals, local zoning ordinances) is out of scope.
Codes are a published contract. A code string is in the warehouse and in customer queries, so codes are added and deprecated — never renamed. Filtering on one is safe to hard-code.
10 · DEMAND
10
DEMAND
DEMAND that a target do, stop or accept something, in wording firmer than an appeal but short of a threat. Code 10 is the root of the demand family, and the residual 100 means the same thing. A demand can carry heavier consequences than an appeal, though lighter ones than a threat. The reporter’s choice of words is the main guide to which of the three applies. Demands are verbal acts.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 100. 10 and 100 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 10 and never 100.
- Code the bare root only when the article reports a demand but gives no basis for choosing among 101-108.
- A demand backed by an explicit threat of retaliation goes to the threaten family (13).
- A demand voiced through demonstrations, strikes or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- A request that lacks the forcefulness reporters use to signal a demand is an appeal (02).
goldstein_scale -5
100
Demand, not specified below
DEMAND or order of a kind that none of the specific codes 101-108 describes. It is the residual of the demand family and a synonym of the bare root 10, retained for compatibility with the official CAMEO code list. Code new events with the bare root 10.
Also covers
- A demand is firmer than an appeal and can carry heavier consequences, yet it stops short of a threat. The reporter’s wording decides which of the three applies. Demands are verbal acts.
- Residual only: it applies when the article does not let you pick one of 101-108, and in that case use the bare root 10.
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 10. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 10 and 100 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 10 when coding; 100 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
101
Demand material cooperation
DEMAND that the target join in some form of material exchange or practical cooperation, where the article does not name the domain. The domains are economic (1011), military (1012), judicial (1013) and intelligence (1014).
Also covers
- ANY demanded material exchange qualifies — economic, military, judicial or intelligence. Demanding information or compliance with an investigation is only ONE instance (the judicial/intelligence flavour), not the whole code.
- Calls to hand over a wanted suspect for trial, or to comply with what an inquiry requires, fall in this family.
- Official sub-categories are 1011 economic, 1012 military, 1013 judicial, 1014 intelligence — all four are carried; use them whenever the article names the domain, and code the bare 101 only when it does not.
- A demand for one-way assistance rather than an exchange belongs under 103 and its sub-codes.
102
Demand policy support
DEMAND that the target extend diplomatic cooperation, either by widening diplomatic ties or by giving non-material backing to a particular policy or position.
Does not cover
- ★ 102 vs 1042 — measured as a live coin-flip, and the test is WHOSE POLICY. 102 demands the target BACK THE SOURCE’S position (support our resolution, endorse our plan, vote with us). 1042 demands the target CHANGE ITS OWN policy (repeal the law, drop the tariff, reverse the decision).
- Narrower diplomatic demands have their own codes in the demand family: a meeting or talks (106), settlement of a dispute (107), or mediation (108).
103
Demand material aid
DEMAND that the target provide material assistance, where the article does not say what kind of aid.
Also covers
- The source may seek aid for itself or for a third party. Either way, the actor expected to supply it is the target.
- Official sub-categories are 1031 economic aid, 1032 military aid, 1033 humanitarian aid, 1034 military protection or peacekeeping — all four are carried; use them whenever the article names the kind of aid, and code the bare 103 only when it does not.
- A demand for MILITARY PROTECTION or for peacekeeping forces is 1034, not this 103 parent.
- A demand for two-way material exchange rather than one-way help belongs under 101.
104
Demand political reform
DEMAND that the target carry out political change, where the kind of change is left unstated. The demand is verbal and carries no threat.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 104 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHAT CHANGE IS DEMANDED. Resign, step down, hold elections → 1041; change a named policy → 1042; grant or restore a named right → 1043; constitution, electoral law, institutions, system of government → 1044.
- The source can be domestic citizens or international actors, speaking for themselves or for others.
- A demand made through demonstrations or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- If the reform sought is in effect a concession by the target, such as lifting administrative restrictions already in place, look for the right code under 105.
105
Demand that target yield
DEMAND that the target yield or make a concession, where the article does not say which concession. Most such demands are verbal, but not all. An outsider, and not only a party to the dispute, may press one or more of the parties, who are coded as targets, to give ground.
Also covers
- Official sub-categories are 1051 ease administrative sanctions, 1052 ease political dissent, 1053 release persons or property, 1054 ease economic sanctions/boycott/embargo, 1055 allow international involvement (non-mediation), 1056 de-escalate military engagement — all six are carried; use them whenever the article names which concession is demanded, and code the bare 105 only when it does not.
- A demand for a CEASEFIRE, military withdrawal or demobilization is 1056, not this 105 parent.
- A demand to yield that comes with a threat belongs under the threaten family (13).
- A demand pressed through protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- When the target actually gives way, code the concession itself under the yield family (08).
106
Demand meeting/negotiation
DEMAND that the target meet, hold talks or negotiate. The act is verbal.
Does not cover
- Pressing the parties to settle their dispute is 107.
- Pressing an outside party to act as mediator, or pressing the adversaries to accept one, is 108.
- A softer request to meet or negotiate, not phrased as a demand, is an appeal (026).
107
Demand settling of dispute
DEMAND that the parties to a conflict reach a settlement, agreement or resolution. Usually, but not always, a verbal act.
Also covers
- The source must be an outside party, never one of the adversaries; it is pressing the parties to settle.
- A demand for a ceasefire, a withdrawal of forces or demobilization is 1056, not 107.
- If one of the adversaries calls for an end to the conflict, that expresses its own intent and is 037, not 107.
108
Demand mediation
DEMAND that a third party mediate a conflict, or that the adversaries accept another party’s mediation. The act is verbal.
Also covers
- Either the adversaries or the prospective mediator may be coded as the target.
- A demand voiced by the would-be mediator itself does not belong here; 108 covers demands from anyone other than a potential mediator.
1011
Demand economic cooperation
DEMAND that the target enter into economic exchange or deepen the economic ties it already has.
Also covers
- Covers demands about trade, investment and other commercial dealings; for example, a government insisting that a partner sign a pending investment treaty.
- A demand for economic aid, a one-way transfer rather than an exchange, is 1031.
1012
Demand military cooperation
DEMAND that the target take up military cooperation or broaden the military relations it has.
Also covers
- Covers demands for defence ties such as joint exercises or arms sales; for example, a government insisting that an ally take part in a planned naval drill.
- A demand for military aid, a one-way transfer rather than an exchange, is 1032.
1013
Demand judicial cooperation
DEMAND that the target begin or deepen cooperation on legal and judicial matters.
Also covers
- Covers demands to extradite or surrender wanted people; for example, a justice ministry insisting that a neighbouring state send back a fugitive banker to face trial.
1014
Demand intelligence cooperation
DEMAND that the target hand over or exchange intelligence or other information.
Also covers
- Covers any demand for intelligence cooperation, of which swapping information on security threats is one case; for example, a parliament insisting that an allied agency release its files on a bombing.
1031
Demand economic aid
DEMAND that the target provide economic assistance such as grants, credit or other financial support. Usually, but not always, the demand is spoken or written.
Also covers
- Pressing for loans or for debt relief counts here; for example, a debtor government urging creditors to write off arrears.
- A demand for two-way economic exchange, such as trade, is 1011.
1032
Demand military aid
DEMAND that the target supply military assistance, for example arms, equipment or training.
Does not cover
- A demand for military protection or for the deployment of peacekeepers is 1034.
1033
Demand humanitarian aid
DEMAND that the target provide humanitarian assistance, such as relief supplies, shelter or refuge.
Also covers
- Covers asylum claims and refugees seeking entry to another country’s territory; the receiving country is the target.
- The act need not be verbal: refugees physically seeking shelter or refuge in a country or region also count.
1034
Demand military protection or peacekeeping
DEMAND that the target provide military protection or send peacekeeping forces.
Also covers
- The protection may be sought for the source itself or for some other party; for example, a regional bloc insisting that the UN station troops along a disputed border.
1041
Change leadership
DEMAND a change of leadership or a shift in who holds power, made verbally and without threat.
Also covers
- Calls for a leader to resign or hand over power belong here, even though such a step is also a form of yielding.
- Calls to hold elections belong here, except calls for a country’s first elections, which count as institutional change (1044).
- A demand made through demonstrations or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
1042
Policy change
DEMAND that the target change a particular policy, made verbally and without threat. The policy and the source may each be domestic or international.
Does not cover
- A demand made through demonstrations or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- If the policy change demanded is really a concession by the target, code it under 105; a call for troops to pull out, for instance, is 1056.
1043
Rights
DEMAND that the target grant or widen social, political or other rights, made verbally and without threat.
Does not cover
- A demand made through demonstrations or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- If the rights demanded amount to a concession by the target, code under 105; a call for compensation for past rights violations is one such case.
1044
Institutional/regime change
DEMAND major change to institutions, to the constitution or to the regime itself. Institutional change differs from policy change because it rewrites the rules by which politics is conducted.
Also covers
- Sweeping demands, such as a call for a transition to multiparty democracy, and narrower ones, such as a call to switch to proportional representation, both belong here. The demand need not aim to topple the regime; seeking to change how the system works is enough.
- A demand for ordinary policy reform is 1042.
1051
Demand easing of administrative sanctions
DEMAND that the target relax or lift administrative restrictions it has imposed.
Also covers
- Use when a government is pressed into a political concession by easing or removing bans, curfews or similar restrictions already in force; for example, a business lobby insisting that the authorities end a night-time curfew.
- A demand made through demonstrations or other protest action belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots).
- A demand to ease economic sanctions, a boycott or an embargo is 1054.
1052
Demand easing of political dissent
DEMAND that the target stop or scale back its political protest activity.
Also covers
- Covers demands to call off demonstrations, strikes and similar action; for example, a ministry insisting that students end their sit-in at a university.
- Only spoken or written demands qualify. If the source moves to suppress the protest by force or other repressive measures, code it in the conflict family.
1053
Demand release of persons or property
DEMAND that the target free people it holds or return property it has taken.
Also covers
- Covers prisoners, hostages and seized property; for example, a shipping firm insisting that a coast guard release an impounded tanker and its crew.
1054
Demand easing of economic sanctions, boycott, or embargo
DEMAND that the target lift or ease economic sanctions, a boycott or an embargo.
Does not cover
- Applies to economic measures only; a demand to ease administrative restrictions is 1051.
1055
Demand to allow international involvement (non-mediation)
DEMAND that the target let international actors in, for example monitors, aid agencies or peacekeeping troops.
Also covers
- For example, a UN envoy insisting that a government admit foreign election monitors.
- A demand that adversaries accept mediation is 108.
1056
Demand de-escalation of military engagement
DEMAND that the target stop fighting or take steps to reduce military conflict or tension.
Also covers
- Covers calls for a ceasefire, a pullback or withdrawal of forces, or demobilization.
11 · DISAPPROVE
11
DISAPPROVE
DISAPPROVE of the target by voicing objection, criticism or complaint. Code 11 is the root of the disapproval family, and the residual 110 means the same thing. Disapproval is usually verbal.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 110. 11 and 110 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 11 and never 110.
- Code the bare root only when the article reports disapproval but gives no basis for choosing among 111-116.
goldstein_scale -2
110
Disapprove, not specified below
DISAPPROVE, object or complain in a way that none of the specific codes 111-116 describes. It is the residual of the disapproval family and a synonym of the bare root 11, retained for compatibility with the official CAMEO code list. Code new events with the bare root 11. Disapproval is usually verbal.
Does not cover
- Residual only: it applies when the article does not let you pick one of 111-116, and in that case use the bare root 11.
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 11. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 11 and 110 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 11 when coding; 110 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
111
Criticize or denounce
CRITICIZE, condemn or denounce a policy or an action, or attack the reputation of those responsible for it.
Also covers
- a same-day public statement by a qualifying official actor criticizing another country or actor is code 111 (criticize/denounce) targeting that country when the statement itself is the article’s concrete news event
- ★ 111 vs 12x — 111 is a JUDGEMENT on something already done or said; 12x is a REFUSAL of something asked of the source. If the article contains a request, offer or proposal that the source turned down, it is 12x however harsh the language.
- ★ 111 vs 13x — 111 looks BACKWARD at conduct; 13x looks FORWARD and names a consequence the source may inflict. “Condemned the strike” is 111; “warned there will be consequences” is 13x.
- 111 vs 161 — condemning a country is 111; actually recalling an envoy, cancelling a summit or downgrading ties is 161, even when the article frames it as a protest.
- A specific charge of wrongdoing against the target is an accusation, coded under 112 and its sub-codes.
- A formal written protest or an organized petition is 114.
112
Accuse
ACCUSE the target of wrongdoing, by blaming or charging it, where no more specific sub-code fits. The code records only that the claim was made; it says nothing about whether the alleged act happened.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 112 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHAT THE TARGET IS ACCUSED OF. If it names the charge, use the child: theft/bribery/fraud/corruption → 1121; torture, arbitrary detention, abuse of civilians → 1122; starting hostilities, ceasefire violation, unjustified military action → 1123; war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide → 1124; spying, espionage, treason → 1125.
113
Rally opposition against
RALLY other parties against the target by urging them to disapprove of it, protest against it or penalize it. Usually, but not always, a verbal act.
Also covers
- For example, a president calling on regional governments to impose travel bans on a neighbouring junta.
- Only diplomatic mobilization counts here; mustering military forces against the target does not.
114
Complain officially
COMPLAIN through a formal written or institutional channel, such as an official protest note, a formal appeal, a petition drive or a recall campaign.
Also covers
- For example, a government delivering a protest note to another state’s ambassador, or residents filing a petition with an ombudsman.
115
Bring lawsuit against
SUE the target by bringing a civil or criminal case against it before a domestic or international court. The plaintiff, or the state when it prosecutes, is the source; the defendant is the target.
116
Find guilty or liable
FIND the target guilty or legally liable in a court ruling. The court, domestic or international, is the source and the defendant is the target. The code mainly covers rulings against non-individuals such as states or organizations, where no prison term is at stake.
Does not cover
- When an individual is convicted and taken into custody, code the detention in the conflict family (Strategic developments: Arrests) or CRIME CR08.
- Bringing the case, as opposed to the ruling on it, is 115.
1121
Crime/corruption
ACCUSE the target of criminal conduct or corruption, whether by allegation, formal charge or blame.
1122
Human rights abuses
ACCUSE the target of human rights violations, for instance torture, slavery or arbitrary detention.
1123
Aggression
ACCUSE the target of starting hostilities, or of military action that is questionable or unjustified, such as breaking a ceasefire.
Does not cover
- If the alleged military conduct is a human rights abuse or a war crime, code 1122 or 1124 instead.
1124
War crimes
ACCUSE the target of taking part in war crimes, whether by allegation, formal charge or blame.
1125
Espionage/treason
ACCUSE the target of spying, espionage or treason, whether by allegation, formal charge or blame.
12 · REJECT
12
REJECT
REJECT or refuse a request, proposal or demand in a way that signals unwillingness to cooperate or to yield. Code 12 is the root of the rejection family, and the residual 120 means the same thing.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 120. 12 and 120 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 12 and never 120.
- Code the bare root only when the article reports a refusal but gives no basis for choosing among 121-129.
120
Reject, not specified below
REJECT or refuse something in a way that none of the specific codes 121-129 describes. It is the residual of the rejection family and a synonym of the bare root 12, retained for compatibility with the official CAMEO code list. Code new events with the bare root 12.
Also covers
- Every rejection in this family must signal that the source will not cooperate or will not give ground.
- Residual only: it applies when the article does not let you pick one of 121-129, and in that case use the bare root 12.
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 12. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 12 and 120 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 12 when coding; 120 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
121
Reject material cooperation
REJECT taking part in, or widening, a material exchange or practical cooperation, where the article does not name the domain.
Also covers
- Official sub-categories are 1211 economic, 1212 military, 1213 judicial, 1214 intelligence — all four are carried; use them whenever the article names the domain, and code the bare 121 only when it does not.
- Refusing to give one-way material assistance, rather than to exchange, is 122.
- Refusing to set up or widen material cooperation is 121; cutting back or ending ties that already exist belongs to the reduce-relations family (16).
122
Reject request for aid
REJECT a request or demand for material aid, declining to supply assistance of a kind the article does not specify.
Also covers
- Official sub-categories are 1221 economic aid, 1222 military aid, 1223 humanitarian aid, 1224 military protection or peacekeeping — all four are carried; use them whenever the article names the kind of aid refused, and code the bare 122 only when it does not.
- Refusing to let humanitarian agencies in, as opposed to refusing to give help oneself, is 1245.
123
Reject political reform request
REJECT a request or demand for political reform, refusing a change the article does not specify.
Also covers
- The target is either the actors who asked for the reform or the country or population affected by the refusal, whichever the article supports.
- Official sub-categories are 1231 change leadership, 1232 change policy, 1233 rights, 1234 change in institutions/regime — all four are carried; use them whenever the article names the reform refused, and code the bare 123 only when it does not.
- If the refused reform is in effect a concession by the source, such as lifting administrative restrictions now in force, look under 124 instead.
124
Refuse to yield
REFUSE to yield or concede, whether by rejecting a request or simply declining, where the article does not say which concession.
Also covers
- Official sub-categories are 1241 ease administrative sanctions, 1242 ease popular dissent, 1243 release persons or property, 1244 ease economic sanctions, 1245 allow international involvement, 1246 de-escalate military engagement — all six are carried; use them whenever the article names which concession is refused, and code the bare 124 only when it does not.
- A refusal to give up power is 1231, not a 124 code.
125
Reject proposal to meet/negotiate (-5.0)
REFUSE to meet, hold discussions or negotiate with another party.
Does not cover
- A refusal to accept mediators, or to meet with mediators, is 126.
goldstein_scale -5
126
Reject mediation (-5.0)
REJECT mediators or mediation initiatives, refusing to let a third party help settle the dispute. The potential mediators are the target.
goldstein_scale -5
127
Reject settlement plan (-5.0)
REJECT a plan, proposal or request meant to settle a conflict comprehensively and for good, such as a peace plan or final resolution. It usually concerns a formal or written plan that aims to end the whole conflict, though other settlement proposals also count.
Also covers
- The target is the opponent the source is in conflict with.
goldstein_scale -5
128
Defy norms/law (-5.0)
DEFY laws or norms by openly disobeying, challenging or resisting them. Covers both civil disobedience by citizens and defiance by officials or governments.
goldstein_scale -5
129
Veto (-5.0)
VETO a legislative proposal, recommendation or resolution, formally blocking it or withholding the assent it needs.
Also covers
- For example, a governor refusing to sign a bill passed by the state legislature.
goldstein_scale -5
1211
Reject economic cooperation
REFUSE to begin or extend economic ties such as trade or investment links.
Also covers
- Covers refusals of two-way economic exchange; for example, a government ruling out a joint pipeline venture proposed by a neighbour.
- Refusing to give financial aid or to forgive debt is 1221.
1212
Reject military cooperation
REFUSE to begin or extend military ties with another party.
Also covers
- Covers refusals of two-way military exchange, for example turning down a proposed joint exercise.
- Refusing to give military aid is 1222.
1213
Reject judicial cooperation
REFUSE to begin or extend cooperation on judicial and legal matters.
Also covers
- Use when the source will not extradite someone or will not assist some other step in a legal proceeding; for example, a state declining to surrender a suspect sought by a foreign court.
- ★ REAL CODE, ABSENT FROM THE APPENDIX. 1213 and 1214 carry full Name/Description/Usage Notes/Example entries in CAMEO 0.9b6 and 1.1b3 § 2.12, but BOTH codebooks omit them from their chapter-6 code list — and GDELT’s cameo.csv, derived from that list, omits them too. The prose is authoritative; the appendix has a gap.
1214
Reject intelligence cooperation
REFUSE to begin or extend cooperation on intelligence or information sharing.
Also covers
- Use when the source declines to investigate a matter or to share what it knows; for example, a government withholding its inquiry findings from an allied service.
- See 1213 on why this code is absent from the codebooks’ own appendix list.
1221
Reject request for economic aid
REFUSE to give financial or other economic assistance.
Also covers
- For example, a lender turning down a government’s plea for an emergency loan.
1222
Reject request for military aid
REFUSE to give military assistance to another party, such as arms or support for a war effort.
1223
Reject request for humanitarian aid
REFUSE to give humanitarian assistance, including relief supplies, shelter or refuge.
Also covers
- Refusing to take in refugees or to give them shelter belongs here.
- If the source blocks humanitarian agencies from gaining access, rather than declining to give help itself, code 1245.
1224
Reject request for military protection or peacekeeping
REFUSE to supply peacekeeping forces or any other form of military protection.
Also covers
- Covers refusals by the would-be providers of protection or peacekeepers.
- When a party to the conflict refuses to let peacekeepers in, code 1245.
1231
Reject request to change leadership
REFUSE to change leadership or to give up power.
Also covers
- Covers refusals to step down or transfer power, and refusals to hold elections that could bring new leaders to office.
- Other refusals to yield go under 124, but a refusal to relinquish power stays here.
1232
Reject request to change policy
REFUSE to change a particular policy when asked or pressed to do so.
Also covers
- Covers refusals to give in to calls for policy change of any kind, whether political, economic, military or social.
- If the policy change would plainly be a form of yielding, use the matching 124x code.
1233
Reject request for rights
REFUSE to grant or uphold rights and freedoms, whether social, political, economic or of another kind.
Does not cover
- If refusing the rights is really a refusal to yield or concede, a 124x code may fit better.
1234
Reject request for change in institutions, regime
REFUSE to make fundamental political change, such as switching to a different system of government or overhauling core institutions or major laws.
Does not cover
- Institutional or regime change is distinct from ordinary policy reform, which is 1232.
1241
Refuse to ease administrative sanctions
REFUSE to relax ADMINISTRATIVE sanctions, such as censorship, a curfew, a state of emergency or martial law, whether by rejecting a request or simply declining.
Does not cover
- Refusing to ease ECONOMIC sanctions, a boycott or an embargo is 1244 — never here. 1241 is ADMINISTRATIVE sanctions only (censorship, curfew, emergency, martial law).
1242
Refuse to ease popular dissent
REFUSE to scale back or end political protest activity, such as demonstrations or rallies.
Also covers
- ★ NOTE THE DIRECTION, as with 082: this is a DISSENTING actor refusing to stand its own protest down, not a government refusing to relax restrictions on dissent (which is 1241).
- For example, opposition leaders vowing to keep their protest camp in the capital despite calls to clear it.
1243
Refuse to release persons
REFUSE to release or hand back people or property, including rejecting requests to do so.
Also covers
- Covers refusals to free or swap prisoners and hostages, and refusals to return property seized earlier.
1244
Refuse to ease economic sanctions, boycott, or embargo
REFUSE to reduce or lift economic sanctions, a boycott or an embargo, including rejecting requests to do so.
Does not cover
- Applies to economic measures only; refusing to ease administrative restrictions is 1241.
1245
Refuse to allow international involvement (non-mediation)
REFUSE to let international actors, for example monitors, aid agencies or peacekeeping troops, gain access to an area or a conflict.
Also covers
- The would-be peacekeepers, observers or other outside actors are the target.
- Blocking humanitarian agencies’ access belongs here rather than 1223, and a party to a conflict refusing entry to peacekeepers belongs here rather than 1224.
- A refusal of mediation is 126.
1246
Refuse to de-escalate military engagement
REFUSE to stop fighting or to take steps that would ease military conflict or tension, including rejecting requests to do so.
Also covers
- Covers rejection of a ceasefire, a withdrawal of forces or demobilization; for example, a militia commander rejecting a call to pull fighters back from a frontline town.
13 · THREATEN
13
THREATEN
Threaten a target by warning that the source will take a coercive or forceful step against it with serious consequences. Most threats are statements rather than physical moves. The bare root 13 covers a threat that none of 131-139 captures; 130 is its residual synonym, kept for compatibility.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 130. 13 and 130 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 13 and never 130.
- Conflictual action reported in the future tense counts as a threat. A report that a militia ‘will storm the capital’ is coded as a threat to attack, not as an attack.
- Fall back on the bare root only when the report gives no basis for choosing among 131-139.
- A threat of force is never 131, which is reserved for threats of non-force measures. A threat is also never 172, which records coercion that has actually been imposed.
- Moves that display military capability, rather than words about intent, belong to root 15.
130
Threaten, not specified below
Threaten a target with a coercive or forceful step where none of the specific threat codes 131-139 applies. 130 is the residual of root 13 and a synonym of the bare root 13. It is kept for compatibility only; use the bare root 13 instead.
Also covers
- Conflictual action reported in the future tense counts as a threat. A report that a militia ‘will storm the capital’ is coded as a threat to attack, not as an attack.
- When no code in 131-139 fits, use the bare root 13, not 130.
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 13. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 13 and 130 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 13 when coding; 130 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
- A threat of force is never 131, which is reserved for threats of non-force measures. A threat is also never 172, which records coercion that has actually been imposed.
131
Threaten non-force
Threaten a target with a non-force measure, such as an aid cut, an economic penalty or a diplomatic downgrade, that the specific codes 1311-1313 do not capture. This is a verbal act.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 131 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHICH NON-FORCE MEASURE IS THREATENED. If it names one, use the child: aid or funding cut → 1311; sanctions, boycott, embargo, tariffs, asset freeze → 1312; expelling diplomats, recalling an ambassador, severing or downgrading ties, quitting a treaty or body → 1313.
- ★ 131 IS NOT THE DEFAULT THREAT CODE. Its label reads as “a threat that is not forceful”; CAMEO means a threat OF NON-FORCE MEASURES, and the measure has to be economic, diplomatic or aid-related. If the article names no such measure, use the bare root 13 — not 131. If it threatens force, it is 138x.
- Non-force measures that are actually carried out belong to root 16 (161-166).
- A threat of administrative penalties, such as a ban or a curfew, is 132.
- A threat to use military force is 138 or one of its sub-codes.
132
Threaten administrative sanctions
Threaten to impose new or wider non-force administrative restrictions or penalties on a target, where the measure is not one of those in 1321-1324.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 132 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHICH ADMINISTRATIVE MEASURE IS THREATENED. If it names one, use the child: speech, press, assembly or protest restrictions → 1321; banning a party, movement or politician → 1322; curfew → 1323; state of emergency or martial law → 1324. 1321 and 1323 have NEVER been emitted in production, and the reason is that their labels (“Political freedoms”, “Curfew”) read as topic tags while the parent label reads as a threat — the parent is not more correct, it is merely better worded.
133
Threaten political dissent/protest
Threaten to stage or join political dissent against a target, for example a street protest, a hunger strike, a labour strike or boycott, a blockade of a building or area, or a riot.
Does not cover
- Dissent that actually takes place is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family (Protests / Riots, e.g. ‘Protest with intervention’).
134
Threaten to halt negotiations
Threaten to walk out of, break off or pull out of talks, negotiations or a meeting with the target. Such threats usually come as a protest against something the target has done or intends to do.
Does not cover
- Negotiations that actually break off are 164.
- ★ 134 REQUIRES THAT NO THIRD-PARTY BROKER IS NAMED. If the article calls the process mediation, or names a mediator, envoy, facilitator or broker working between the sides, the threat to quit is 135 instead — the same one-word test that governs 164 vs 165.
135
Threaten to halt mediation
Threaten to stop mediating, or to stop taking part in mediated talks. This is a verbal act. The threat can come from the mediator or from one of the disputing parties.
Does not cover
- Mediation that actually ends is 165.
- ★ 135 vs 134 — decidable on ONE WORD, and 135 has NEVER been emitted in production because nothing told the coder to look for it. If the article calls the process MEDIATION, or names a THIRD PARTY who is brokering between the two sides (a mediator, envoy, facilitator, broker, “talks brokered by X”), the threat to walk away is 135. Only two-party talks with no broker are 134.
- Threats to remove peacekeepers, inspectors, observers or aid agencies go to 136, not 135.
136
Threaten to halt international involvement
Threaten to scale back or end an international presence other than mediation, by expelling or withdrawing observers, aid agencies, peacekeepers or similar actors.
Also covers
- Both directions count: an international body warning that it will pull its people out, and a host state warning that it will throw them out.
- Threats that concern mediation are 135.
137
Threaten with repression
Threaten dissidents with forcible suppression. Threats to jail opponents, or to break up opposition activity by force, belong here.
Does not cover
- Repressing dissidents differs from fighting another armed group, even when police or security forces would use violence. A threat of military force or of battle is 138.
goldstein_scale -7
138
Threaten with military force
Threaten to use military force against a target where the kind of force is not one of those in 1381-1385. This is a verbal act.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 138 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHAT KIND OF FORCE IS THREATENED. If it names one, use the child: blockade, closing a strait, sealing a border by force → 1381; occupying or seizing territory → 1382; terrorism, assassination, sabotage → 1383; strikes, missiles, air raids, invasion, “military action” → 1384; nuclear/chemical/biological/radiological weapons, OR mass expulsion, mass killing or ethnic cleansing → 1385.
- Moves that actively show readiness to use force, rather than statements of intent, belong to root 15.
- Force that is actually used is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family.
goldstein_scale -7
139
Give ultimatum
Issue an ultimatum, a last warning or final demand whose rejection would expose the target to retaliation by the issuing party. This is usually a verbal act.
Also covers
- The test rests on how the event is reported. Code 139 when the source uses the word ‘ultimatum’; without that word, treat the demand as an ordinary threat under 13x.
- DEFINITION MISMATCH, RESOLVED BY THE 10-20 MERGE — kept because the distinction is easy to lose: the authored definition this replaced defined 139 structurally, as “a demand with an explicit deadline and a stated consequence”. That is an authored test, not the official one. Official CAMEO keys 139 on the reporter’s WORDING; a deadline-plus-consequence demand that no source calls an ultimatum is an ordinary threat under 13x.
goldstein_scale -7
1311
Threaten to stop aid
Threaten to cut back or end the supply of material aid to a target. The aid may be economic, military or humanitarian support, or a peacekeeping contribution.
1312
Threaten to boycott/sanction
Threaten to cut off or limit normal economic dealings with a target through sanctions, a boycott or an embargo. The aim is to punish the target or register protest by curbing trade and similar transactions.
Does not cover
- Sanctions or an embargo that are actually put in place are 163.
1313
Threaten to break relations
Threaten to scale back relations with a target or to cut ties with it formally.
Also covers
- This covers non-force threats to secede or declare independence, to step down from office, to recall diplomats, and to downgrade or end diplomatic ties.
1321
Political freedoms
Threaten to impose or extend limits on basic political freedoms, such as free speech, free expression or the right to assemble.
Does not cover
- If the threat signals that repressive force will be used to make the limits stick, code 137.
1322
Ban parties
Threaten to bar particular parties or individual politicians from political activity.
Does not cover
- A threat to jail the target or to subject it to other repression is 137.
1323
Curfew
Threaten to impose a curfew that would keep residents of an area off the streets and out of public spaces after a set hour.
1324
Emergency
Threaten to declare a state of emergency or impose martial law, which would set aside some constitutional rights or the constitution as a whole.
1381
Threaten blockade
Threaten to use military means to stop people or goods from entering or leaving a territory. Such threats are usually verbal.
1382
Threaten occupation
Threaten to occupy a territory, or to take control of all or part of it. Such threats are usually verbal.
Does not cover
- An occupation that has been or is being carried out is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family.
1383
Threaten unconventional violence
Threaten unconventional violence, such as a terrorist attack, an assassination or sabotage. Such threats are usually verbal. The label is the CAMEO v0.9b5 name; v1.1b3 calls the code ‘Threaten unconventional attack’.
Does not cover
- Unconventional violence that has actually taken place is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family.
- ★ 1383 vs 1385 — the discriminator is SCALE, stated in the text. A threat aimed at a person, a building or a unit (assassination, a bombing, sabotage, a terror attack) is 1383. A threat whose stated object is a POPULATION — nuclear/chemical/biological weapons, wiping out a city, mass expulsion, mass killing, ethnic cleansing — is 1385. No weapon of mass destruction needs to be mentioned for 1385.
1384
Threaten conventional attack
Threaten to attack a party or to use conventional weapons against it. Such threats are usually verbal.
1385
Threaten unconventional mass violence
Threaten force that could harm large numbers of people, whether through weapons of mass destruction (nuclear, chemical, biological or radiological), mass expulsion, mass killing or ethnic cleansing. Such threats are usually verbal. The threatened act, if carried out, would belong to the conflict family as mass violence, or to DEMOGRAPHIC DE02 for a mass expulsion. The label is the CAMEO v1.1b3 name; v0.9b5 called the code ‘Threaten attack with WMD’, a name dropped here because it left out mass atrocities.
Also covers
- A weapon of mass destruction is one route into this code, not a requirement. A threatened mass expulsion, mass killing or ethnic cleansing qualifies even when no such weapon is mentioned.
- Mass violence that is actually carried out belongs to the conflict family; a mass expulsion that is carried out goes to DEMOGRAPHIC DE02 for mass removals.
- Threats of unconventional violence on a smaller scale, such as terrorism or an assassination, are 1383.
15 · EXHIBIT FORCE POSTURE
15
EXHIBIT FORCE POSTURE
Display military or police power without actually using force, typically by showing capability and readiness to act. The bare root 15 covers such a move when none of 151-155 captures it; 150 is its residual synonym, kept for compatibility. The label is the CAMEO v0.9b5 name; v1.1b3 calls the category EXHIBIT MILITARY POSTURE.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 150. 15 and 150 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 15 and never 150.
- For 15 and codes 150-153 the source need not be a state military; any organized armed group can be the source. The target is the party the source is building up against in a threatening way.
- Actual use of force is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family. Posture stops short of force and mainly shows capability and readiness.
- A threat alone is root 13. Threats are usually verbal and involve no action taken to display military power.
goldstein_scale -7.2
150
Demonstrate military or police power
Display military or police power short of using force where none of 151-155 applies. 150 is the residual of root 15 and a synonym of the bare root 15. It is kept for compatibility only; use the bare root 15 instead.
Does not cover
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 15. There is no article-decidable difference between them; the tie is broken by convention — ALWAYS EMIT 15, NEVER 150. 150 is carried only so a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
- When the report says what was raised or mobilized, use the specific code: a police alert is 151, a military alert 152, extra police 153, extra troops 154 and added cyber capacity 155.
- Force that is actually used is not coded in POLITICAL; it belongs to the conflict family.
- A threat made only in words, with no display of power, is root 13.
151
Increase police alert status
Raise the alert or readiness level of police or other internal security forces, signalling that they stand prepared to use force. The CAMEO codebook gives this code a name only; its description, usage notes and example are placeholders. This definition rests on the name, on the root 15 rule that the move stops short of force, and on the parallel with 152 for the military.
Does not cover
- A raised alert for the military rather than the police is 152.
- Sending more police or building up police numbers, without a change in alert status, is 153.
152
Increase military alert status
Raise military readiness and caution so that forces stand prepared to use force. Formal orders putting the military on alert belong here. The target is the party the military move is aimed at.
Does not cover
- A raised alert for the police rather than the military is 151.
- A rise in force numbers, such as troops deployed or called up, rather than a higher readiness level, is 154.
153
Mobilize/increase police power
Deploy or build up police forces to show strength, mainly to intimidate. The codebook’s description field for 153 repeats the text it gives for 154, an apparent copy error. This definition follows 153’s usage notes, which are what set it apart from 154.
Does not cover
- ★ ROOT 15 IS A 2x2 GRID, and both axes are stated in the article. WHO: police/gendarmerie/interior forces → 151/153; army/navy/air force/armed groups → 152/154. WHAT: a READINESS LEVEL raised, put on alert, alert status → 151/152; NUMBERS moved, deployed, called up, reinforced, more personnel or weapons → 153/154. Police + numbers is 153, which is this code.
- If armed forces rather than police are built up, use 154.
- A higher police alert level, rather than more police, is 151.
154
Mobilize/increase armed forces
Increase the number of military personnel or weapons, for example by deploying extra troops, reinforcing a garrison or moving in more weapons. The target is the party the military move is aimed at.
Does not cover
- A build-up of police rather than armed forces is 153.
- ★ ROOT 15 IS A 2x2 GRID, and both axes are stated in the article. WHO: police/gendarmerie/interior forces → 151/153; army/navy/air force/armed groups → 152/154. WHAT: a READINESS LEVEL raised, put on alert, alert status → 151/152; NUMBERS moved, deployed, called up, reinforced, more personnel or weapons → 153/154. Armed forces + numbers is 154, which is this code.
- A higher military alert status, rather than more forces, is 152. A show of force that names neither an alert level nor a troop increase, such as a flypast, a port call, a missile test or an exercise near a border, is the bare root 15.
155
Mobilize or increase cyber-forces
Build up the means to conduct cyber warfare, for example by creating a cyber command or expanding a hacking unit. This code was added in CAMEO v1.1b3 and does not exist in v0.9b5/0.9b6.
Also covers
- Code 155 only when the build-up is aimed at one or more specific targets. It may be offensive or defensive.
- A cyberattack that is actually carried out is 176.
- Like all of root 15, this is posture: a show of capability and readiness that stops short of using force.
- Cyber operations that are coded outside POLITICAL belong to TECHNOLOGY TE03, not here.
16 · REDUCE RELATIONS
16
REDUCE RELATIONS
Reduce or cut back normal, routine or cooperative relations with a target. Use the bare root 16 when none of 161-166 fits; 160 is its residual synonym, kept for compatibility.
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 160. 16 and 160 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 16 and never 160.
- Root 16 is a fallback: use the bare root only when the report gives no basis for choosing among 161-166.
- Non-force threats coded under 131 end up in root 16 once they are actually carried out.
160
Reduce relations, not specified below
Reduce normal, routine or cooperative relations with a target where none of 161-166 applies. 160 is the residual of root 16 and a synonym of the bare root 16. It is kept for compatibility only; use the bare root 16 instead.
Also covers
- Non-force threats coded under 131 end up in root 16 once they are actually carried out.
- When no code in 161-166 fits, use the bare root 16, not 160.
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 16. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 16 and 160 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 16 when coding; 160 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
161
Reduce/break diplomatic relations (-4.0)
Scale back, suspend or end diplomatic exchange with a target, up to a full break in diplomatic relations.
Also covers
- This covers cancelled official visits or meetings, recalled or expelled diplomats, and the ending of other diplomatic activity.
- Ending negotiations is 164 and ending mediation is 165, not 161.
- Expelling or withdrawing non-diplomats goes elsewhere: peacekeepers, inspectors or aid agencies are 166, and private individuals are 174.
- ★ THE THREE-WAY EXPULSION TEST, decidable from WHO the article names. Diplomats, an ambassador, embassy or consular staff, a mission accredited to the state → 161. An ORGANISATION or its personnel — peacekeepers 1661, inspectors or observers 1662, aid agencies or NGOs 1663. Private individuals, migrants, journalists, a named person deported → 174.
goldstein_scale -4
162
Reduce/stop aid (-5.6)
Cut back or stop material aid to a target where the type of aid is not specified.
Also covers
- Use the sub-codes when the report names the kind of aid: 1621 economic, 1622 military, 1623 humanitarian. Code the bare 162 only when it does not.
- If the aid provider is expelled or pulls out, rather than the aid itself being cut, use 1663.
goldstein_scale -5.6
163
Impose embargo/sanctions (-8.0)
Impose an embargo, boycott or sanctions, halting or limiting trade or other material exchange with a target to punish it or to protest its conduct.
Also covers
- This is the carried-out form of the threat coded 1312. Non-force threats that are acted on land in root 16.
- A threat of sanctions is 1312.
- Lifting or easing sanctions is 085.
- A demand that sanctions be eased is 0254.
goldstein_scale -8
164
Halt negotiations (-7.0)
Break off talks or negotiations with a target. This covers failed negotiations, walk-outs and other disruption of planned talks, whether one side ends them or several sides do.
Does not cover
- A threat to break off negotiations is 134.
- ★ 164 REQUIRES THAT NO THIRD-PARTY BROKER IS NAMED. If the article calls the process mediation, or names a mediator, envoy, facilitator or broker, the collapse is 165 instead. This is the same one-word test as 134 vs 135, and it is decidable from the text every time.
goldstein_scale -7
165
Halt mediation (-6.5)
End mediation efforts between disputing parties. The source is usually the mediator or mediators, and failed mediation is coded here.
Does not cover
- A threat to stop mediating is 135.
goldstein_scale -6.5
166
Expel/withdraw
Remove groups or organizations from a territory, by expelling them or through their own withdrawal, where the group is not identified more specifically. Both expulsion by the host authority and withdrawal by the guest group or organization count.
Also covers
- ★ CODE THE BARE 166 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT IDENTIFY WHO WAS EXPELLED OR WITHDRAWN. If it names them, use the child: peacekeepers, a peacekeeping mission, a stabilisation force, blue helmets → 1661; inspectors, monitors, observers, a verification or election-monitoring mission, IAEA/OPCW staff → 1662; aid agencies, NGOs, relief organisations, humanitarian staff, MSF/ICRC/WFP → 1663.
- Measured 2026-08: 166 held 236 events while 1661 and 1662 held ZERO and 1663 held 3. Nothing about the world produces that distribution — the parent was absorbing named cases because its label is the only one in the group that says what the act is.
- Expelling or deporting individual people, usually through a legal process, is 174.
- Mass expulsions of populations go to DEMOGRAPHIC DE02 for mass removals.
- When hostile military forces pull out, that is a form of yielding and is coded 0874.
- Expelling or withdrawing diplomats is 161.
1621
Reduce or stop economic assistance
Cut back or stop the provision of economic aid to a target.
Does not cover
- If the aid provider is expelled or pulls out, rather than the aid itself being cut, use 1663.
1622
Reduce or stop military assistance
Cut back or stop the provision of military aid to a target.
Does not cover
- If the aid provider is expelled or pulls out, rather than the aid itself being cut, use 1663.
1623
Reduce or stop humanitarian assistance
Cut back or stop the provision of humanitarian aid to a target.
Does not cover
- If the aid provider is expelled or pulls out, rather than the aid itself being cut, use 1663.
1661
Expel or withdraw peacekeepers
Remove peacekeeping forces from a territory or end their deployment, by expelling them or by withdrawing them. Both expulsion by the host state and a voluntary pull-out by the contributing actor count.
Also covers
- Source rule: in an expulsion the host state is the source; in a withdrawal the actor that supplied the forces is the source.
1662
Expel or withdraw inspectors
Remove inspectors or other observers from a territory, by expelling them or by withdrawing them. Both expulsion by the host state and withdrawal by the body that sent them count.
Also covers
- Observers such as election monitors and ceasefire monitors are covered along with inspectors. The full CAMEO name is ‘Expel or withdraw inspectors, observers’.
1663
Expel or withdraw aid agencies
End the presence of non-governmental organizations that help civilians, including aid agencies, by expelling them or by withdrawing them. Both expulsion by the host state and withdrawal by the aid provider count.
Does not cover
- If aid is only cut or halted and the report does not mention the provider being expelled or leaving, use 1623.
17 · COERCE
17
COERCE
Coerce a population or its members through repression, or through force aimed at civilians, their rights or their property. Use the bare root 17 when none of the carried leaves fits; 170 is its residual synonym, kept for compatibility. Root 17 is not limited to non-violent acts: force against property (171 and its sub-codes) belongs here. The taxonomy limits the set of sub-codes it carries; it does not change what the root means. Sub-codes that coerce persons directly are coded elsewhere (see excludes).
Also covers
- PREFER THIS BARE ROOT OVER 170. 17 and 170 are the identical “family but no leaf” answer; there is no article-decidable difference. When no leaf fits, emit 17 and never 170.
- Codes carried under this root: 171, 1711 and 1712 (force against property), 172 and 1721-1724 (administrative sanctions), 174 (expelling or deporting individuals) and 176 (cyberattack).
- Taking, confiscating or destroying property belongs to root 17 even though it is a use of force. Root 17 is not a non-violent family, so do not steer such acts elsewhere on that basis; 171 and its sub-codes carry the taxonomy’s most conflictual Goldstein value (-9.2).
- Arrests and detentions are not coded here; they go to the conflict family (Strategic developments: Arrests) or CRIME CR08.
- Violent repression, such as breaking up dissent by force, is not coded here; it belongs to the conflict family.
170
Coerce, not specified below
Coerce through repression, or through force aimed at civilians, their rights or their property, where none of the carried sub-codes of root 17 applies. 170 is the residual of root 17 and a synonym of the bare root 17. It is kept for compatibility only; use the bare root 17 instead.
Does not cover
- SAME MEANING AS THE BARE ROOT 17. This taxonomy makes 2-digit roots assignable, so 17 and 170 denote the identical “family but no leaf” case. Prefer the bare root 17 when coding; 170 is carried because it is the official CAMEO spelling and so that a caller filtering on official CAMEO gets a valid subcategory rather than a 400.
- Coercion aimed directly at persons is not coded here, and 170 is not a back door for it. Arrests and detentions go to the conflict family (Strategic developments: Arrests) or CRIME CR08; violent repression goes to the conflict family.
171
Seize or damage property (-9.2)
Use force against property, or violate property rights, in a way that neither 1711 (confiscate) nor 1712 (destroy) captures.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 171 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHETHER THE PROPERTY WAS TAKEN OR WRECKED. Taken, held, seized, confiscated, expropriated, nationalized, frozen, looted → 1711. Destroyed, demolished, burned, razed, blown up → 1712.
goldstein_scale -9.2
172
Impose administrative sanctions (-5.0)
Curb civilians’ rights through a formal instrument such as a decree, law, regulation or official policy, where the restriction is not one of those in 1721-1724.
Also covers
- CODE THE BARE 172 ONLY WHEN THE ARTICLE DOES NOT SAY WHICH RESTRICTION WAS IMPOSED. If it names one, use the child: speech, press, internet, assembly or protest restrictions → 1721; banning a party, movement or politician → 1722; curfew → 1723; state of emergency or martial law → 1724. Measured 2026-08: 172 carried 2,622 events against 226 across all four children combined, which is a wording artefact and not a real distribution.
- Use 172 only for coercion that has actually been imposed. If it is only threatened, use a 13x code, with 132 for administrative measures.
- ★ 172 vs 163 — the shared word “sanctions” is not the discriminator. 172 restricts what PEOPLE MAY DO (speech, assembly, movement, party activity). 163 restricts what may be TRADED, SHIPPED, SOLD or BANKED. An asset freeze, an export ban or a designation of a firm or an individual under a sanctions programme is 163, never 172.
- ★ 172 vs 170/17 — 172 requires a NAMED formal instrument (a decree, law, order, regulation or ban) actually curbing civil rights. Coercion with no such instrument in the text is the bare root 17, not 172.
- SCOPE NOTE: official 172 is specifically about decrees curbing CIVILIANS’ RIGHTS, not administrative measures in general. A regulatory or licensing action that does not curb civil rights is not a 172.
goldstein_scale -5
174
Expel or deport individuals (-5.0)
Expel or deport individual people from a territory through a formal removal, usually after a legal process.
Does not cover
- Expelling diplomats is a cut in diplomatic relations and is coded 161.
- Expelling peacekeepers, inspectors or aid agencies belongs to 166 and its sub-codes.
- Mass expulsions, such as removals aimed at ethnic cleansing, go to DEMOGRAPHIC DE02 for mass removals.
goldstein_scale -5
176
Attack cybernetically
Attack computers, networks or online accounts without legal right or authorization. This code was added in CAMEO v1.1b3 and does not exist in v0.9b5/0.9b6.
Also covers
- Cyberattacks take many forms and serve many motives. Examples include defacing a ministry website, stealing officials’ emails or databases, and knocking a government network offline.
- Building up cyber capacity against a named target, without an attack, is posture and is coded 155.
- ★ CROSS-DOMAIN BOUNDARY, READ BEFORE USING: CAMEO+ also carries TECHNOLOGY code TE03 CYBER EVENT (“large-scale attack, critical infrastructure breach, ransomware, zero-day exploit”), which covers the same real-world act. Use 176 only when the cluster is already POLITICAL — a state or named political actor coercing another through a cyberattack. A cyber incident routed to TECHNOLOGY is TE03 and must NOT be double-coded here.
- Cyber operations that are coded outside POLITICAL belong to TECHNOLOGY TE03, not here.
1711
Confiscate property
Take control of another party’s property by force, for example by confiscating or expropriating it. Raids and looting count here, as do other forced seizures.
1712
Destroy property
Destroy or demolish property by force, for example by torching vehicles, razing a market or blowing up a bridge.
1721
Restrict political freedoms
Restrict or violate core political rights, such as the freedoms of speech, expression and assembly. Curbs on the press and on dissent activity belong here.
Does not cover
- If the event is the enforcement of such limits by repressive means, it is not coded here. Jailing people goes to the conflict family (Strategic developments: Arrests) or CRIME CR08, and breaking up demonstrations goes to the conflict family (Protests / Riots, e.g. ‘Protest with intervention’).
1722
Ban political parties
Ban political parties or politicians, either by stopping a party from forming or by barring a party or politician from political activity.
Does not cover
- A threat to impose such a ban is 1322.
1723
Impose curfew
Impose a curfew that keeps residents of an area off the streets and out of public spaces after a set hour.
Does not cover
- A threatened curfew is 1323.
1724
Impose state of emergency/martial law
Declare a state of emergency or put an area under martial law, setting aside ordinary constitutional rights and procedures.
Does not cover
- A threat to declare an emergency or martial law is 1324.

